I completely understand where Henchling is coming from, I've always thrown taunting into the same bracket of tea bagging, and that really can only be processed one of 2 ways.
A meaningless joke or a personal attack.
The likelihood of it being interpreted as the latter is more probable if you're somewhat of an outsider to this community, and as such it does not strike you as a very warm welcome. But I'd also wager a guess that the overwhelming majority simply ignore taunting, but that don't mean they like it or want it, they just tolerate it.
Now my personal stance on taunting is that I've never cared for it and that goes for every game I've played, i could take it or leave it and it wouldn't bother me. But if i was to take my personal bias out of the equation then i can see the issue.
I'm not going to lie, i do think this has been blown way out of proportions and a mountain has been made of a molehill, but that does not mean that said molehill should be ignored.
I feel like Klu is the forum equivalent of the drunk stranger on the street who walks up to you and your friends and tries to tell you all what we're doing wrong in life.
Once again, thanks for your input.
Tue Nov 26, 2013 5:03 pm
Spandex
HH Donor
Joined: Thu Sep 04, 2008 5:45 pm Posts: 765 Location: In your ass.
STEAM_0:1:20363180
Re: Taunting
henchling wrote:
I find it very strange that this behaviour is simply being accepted as "part of the game".
Maybe because it is part of the game?
henchling wrote:
The issue has never been about being annoyed by the occasional taunt from people on the server, nor is it because these people kill me over and over again and I'm just irrationally annoyed that people are better at me at games on the internet.
What, seriously?
henchling wrote:
I would ask, why be tolerant of a behaviour that is annoying?
If life just was this simple...
henchling wrote:
Off topic: I've noticed that the clan has been very tolerant of a certain player that has appended the word #rape to their name. I wonder what SgtHardplace would make of it.
I think you are trying too hard now. Just quit it before you make yourself look like a fool.
_________________ HH Cup Season 1 Champion HH Cup Season 2 Champion
Quote:
Dia: You're in heaven when you're sitting next to me.
I feel like Klu is the forum equivalent of the drunk stranger on the street who walks up to you and your friends and tries to tell you all what we're doing wrong in life.
You think that I'm trying too hard when I point out that someone has been playing on the server with an offensive name?
I just figured that one of your admins would have asked them to change it when playing here by now.
I mentioned SgtHardplace because I think he made his thoughts on the use of the word quite well in this thread: viewtopic.php?f=32&t=8589&hilit=rape
Specifically:
SgtHardPlace wrote:
See me get on my high horse. Look, here I go...
You're all welcome to take this however you like. If you want to be insulted, go ahead, but this is my opinion and last time I checked there aren't any rules against expressing it, and people get away with slagging each other off on here all the damn time.
There have been a few comments made that sexual harassment doesn't really exist in the online gaming community.
That's bullshit. It's pervasive, and often invisible, but it exists. It exists on the HH just as it exists anywhere else.
An example I'm dredging up from memory: Rusty, Beth, Starbuck - all girls (I believe) - all talked about by members and ex-members of the community in a manner which objectified and reduced them to purely sexual beings. I reckon there are posts in the archives that'll back this up, but I've watched/heard it happen on Mumble and on TF2.
Sometimes something 'very bad' happens like that fighting tourney, and it gets press media, but for every incident like that which gets coverage, there are hundreds that don't.
>90% of the members and regs of the HH are male. In general men don't see sexual harassment because we're socialised into a male-dominated world - the patriarchy as the feminists call it. And that is sadly true.
Another example, which whilst not direct sexual harassment simply perpetuates the macho bullshit male gamer stereotype and the culture of oppression (because that's what it is, despite the defensive knee-jerk reactions I'm going to get from the people who feel offended at this) is Rape.
Rape is a word with a number of connotations and a number of dictionary definitions. A unit of land measurement, a type of seed crop, oh yeah, and non-consensual coercive sexual activity, often violent.
It also gets thrown around completely casually by many members of this community. Why?
Because it's all about dominating, humiliating, owning, having power over and otherwise completely defeating an opponent.
Doesn't sound like anything to do with land measurements to me.. nor seed crops. Sexual violence anyone?
'But we don't mean it like that'. Bullshit. It's used exactly in that context. Sure it might not mean you literally took your cock out and stuck it in an unresisting or coerced foe, but it's *definitely* used in the context of having power over another. It's used to degrade, it's used to big yourselves up, it's used to show off how great, how powerful, how much of a winner you are.
Statistics estimate that 1 in 4 women have been the victim of some kind of sexual violence. I don't know what the figure is for men but it's much much lower.
To talk about 'totally raping that guy' is to degrade them utterly, no matter what your intent, and it's pathetic.
I hear it on mumble a lot, and I try to call people on it when it happens. And guess what happens... That's right folks! I get a whole heap of defensive self-justifying knee jerk reactions from the people doing it because they don't get how pervasive, how invisible and how fucking priveliged they are not to have to worry about the threat of sexual violence. If they did they'd not be tossing the language around so casually. I bring it up and *I'm* the bad guy. Fuck that shit. I happen to know full well that others agree with me, but no-one else wants to say anything because they don't want to have to deal with the same kind of bullshit reaction that I get.
And people wonder why I don't hang around much any more.
The best answer to not receive abuse online is for there to be clear rules that abuse will not be tolerated. And for there to be active moderation to handle that abuse, and for communities to actively police themselves - as Fluffy says. Sadly though, I don't see the HH doing very much of this where it's needed - although thankfully it's not common on the forums.
So yeah, there's my soap box.
There's even some points in here relevant to the issue that started this thread.
Tue Nov 26, 2013 5:28 pm
Sam
HH Donor
Joined: Sun Mar 23, 2008 11:44 pm Posts: 3761 Location: Leicester, UK
STEAM_0:0:15279954
Re: Taunting
I've changed my mind, I can see where henchling is coming from and I think the plugin would be a good idea (or at least not a bad idea).
Also, I don't like that name with '#rape' at the end but I don't know what our policy is (or should be) on this. edit - sarge's post is very good
Last edited by Sam on Tue Nov 26, 2013 5:39 pm, edited 2 times in total.
I say we ban anyone who actively expresses the opinion of enjoying tf2 and remove all current features and/or content that is part of the default game.
I am just gobsmacked to come back here and see a thread of one of the most trivial things that has ever been written about has now reached 9 pages.
Then, precedes to add to the thread, that is pretty much resolved, by writing a wall of text that repeats (with a dash of vitriol) what has already been said over the last 9 pages, and stirs up the ashes.
dazed wrote:
I'm not going to reply to you again as you're not someone I wish to even converse with.
Stir up the ashes? There were no ashes, the thread was far from resolved, and it will go on and on. My whole post was an attempt to resolve it by knocking into certain people's heads that this is trivial and childish and should end here, it was an attempt to end the thread not stir it.
And I wasn't replying to henchling or entering into conversation with him in that previous post or this one, so i'm not sure why you quoted that last bit
"the fact that we have taunted constantly at everyone for about 3 years, and you're the first one to get angry about it......." - So, being an a**hole for 3 years makes it OK?
"2nd, if you have a problem with people taunting you should probably quit fps games." - I've never had this problem in any other online fps. You're clearly a special case.
"henchling went mental and made a thread about people taunting." - I'm not sure I'd characterise creating a thread to discuss a valid issue as "went mental".
"cause hes a very very angry boy." - Nope. Not angry. You sound pretty angry, from my perspective.
Dazed forum posts:
"you called me and zerged "pricks" only yesterday simply because we taunted you" - Factually incorrect. I called Zerged a prick, reacting to his actions. That might have been ill-advised, but it's hardly the worst of my apparent sins, all things considered.
"You constantly get angry at people over nothing on the server and every regular on the server knows this and has been a witness to your poor attitude." - Hyperbole. Also, if we're talking about attitudes, you're pretty notorious for being something of a grouch yourself.
"you ... should maybe look for another server to play on." - Who knows, maybe you'll get your wish.
"Me, Zerged and others have taunted almost every kill for 3 years or more" - Maybe, maybe not. Still makes you seem like an a**hole to me.
"clearly you have issues outside of tf2" - Meaningless, childish, attempt to undermine my point.
"you should deal with them without taking your insecurities out of players on the server." - I'm pretty sure I reserve most of my more salty remarks for reacting to your little gang. Insecurity doesn't factor into it.
"I'm not going to reply to you again as you're not someone I wish to even converse with." - Yeah, you're really above this.
In the space of a day, Dazed has slung more personal insults than I have in years. Clearly his constant, unchecked, taunting is the product of a similarly rational mindset.
Tue Nov 26, 2013 8:59 pm
Spandex
HH Donor
Joined: Thu Sep 04, 2008 5:45 pm Posts: 765 Location: In your ass.
STEAM_0:1:20363180
Re: Taunting
I really find it amusing how taunting has been there since beginning for many years, yet only now its a problem, and a huge one apparently.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum